Friday, 4 September 2015

The "Iron Harvest"...when things just don't want to match up

Where the 22nd of July had so many overwhelming moments: from the sea of headstones to the endless columns of names of the missing, to relief for learning a way to see the experience in a new, life affirming way, the 23rd of July was almost the opposite.  The spirit linking the experiences was not one of sameness but one of contrast.  So many moments of this day were incongruous:  from healing to murder; from cemeteries on the busiest of roads to finding them, once more in beautiful, peaceful places making them more like parks than places where the dead rest; from realising once again that deep below the surface of the fertile fields lie, what Scott called, the “iron harvest.” So many strange pairings on this day.

The whole day had really strange “energy” right from the start.  We were down a body because my female compatriot, Elaine, was exhausted and wanted to stay behind and rest.  With a person missing, the van really wasn’t the same.  I think, too, that is many ways I wasn’t “over” the visits of the previous day.  There were a lot of big emotions to process, as I shared in the last post, and that depth of experience really needed time and distance to settle.  In addition to all of that, it was our second to last day of the tour…really our last day of just visiting cemeteries.  The next day we would be returning to Paris to the hotel near the airport and preparing to return to Canada.  I was not really sure if I really wanted to go home yet.  I missed my family but I was enjoying learning all that I had learned and I was not sure that I wanted that to end just yet.

Working through that now, I see that with all of those conflicting feelings, this second to last day could not have been anything other than incongruous…it makes sense that nothing seemed to just come together like it did the day before.  Even subtleties of the day conflicted, or had interesting ironies about them.  Let’s start with our first stop of the day (…see what I did there?).
 
We started our day at the bunker where Canadian field doctor John Mc Crae worked for seventeen days during the Second Battle of Ypres in his dressing station and the place where he was inspired to write In Flanders Fields. 
McCrea's bunker
McCrae was an epidemiologist from an Ontario hospital before the war.  After his time in the dressing stations in Flanders, he moved on to France where he worked at the head of a hospital.  He died in 1918 of pneumonia…a doctor of infectious diseases died of an infectious disease…see where this day is going?  I told you the energy of the day was strange.

Back to the bunker:  this is the place where Dr. Mc Crae tried desperately, in desperate conditions, to make shattered men whole and where he lost his best friend Alexis Helmer.  It was extremely powerful to be there in that place where a piece of Art was born.  Admittedly, I am not the biggest fan of the poem as a poem but, rather, find respect for it as a commentary piece.  Its importance lies in what it represented and how the soldiers of the day said, time and again, how it perfectly described the conditions, the world of the war.  On a warm summer’s day, there are plenty of poppies in that place.  There were the days I visited.
Essex Farm Cemetery - the cemetery connected to McCrea's
dressing station.  The hill in the background is covered
with poppies.


We returned to this place the following day, on the 24th, to give Elaine a chance to see it.  I will revisit the experience on that day in another post because it has magic of its own.
















Our next stop was the Lijssenthoek Military Cemetery.  This cemetery was interesting because it was a hospital cemetery and we had not visited a hospital cemetery to that point.  The headstones rather than being placed “willy nilly,” as they were in some cemeteries (especially cemeteries which were original to the battlefields) were in perfect rows, the names were in alphabetical order, and in order of the date of death.  In addition, there was a headstone of a nursing sister- only one of two buried in the whole of France from this time period.  I found this very interesting.

This cemetery was large but did not have the same heaviness of Tyne Cot or the Menin Gate.  Unlike Tyne Cot or Menin Gate, this place had no consistency of “feeling” or “energy.”  Some sections felt peaceful or resigned while others, it seems, resonated fear and resistance…feelings I am sure many of those men felt in their last, tortured days in the hospital surrounded by varying degrees of suffering, dying, and death or, for some, comfort. 

In order to access the cemetery, you have to go through an information centre which explained the difference between field hospitals, dressing stations, hospitals, and so on.  There were pictures, maps and diagrams of the area, how the light rail systems were set up to deliver supplies to the front lines and bring back the wounded on the return trip.  What this meant was, if you had a rail map of the area from the Great War, chances are that today cemeteries, along the same route, were probably dressing stations of some kind.  Again, the history comes to life when you have this information.  With that knowledge, it makes sense now why so many of the cemeteries, on that day, were connected to field hospitals – they were all on the light rail route connecting them to Lijssenthoek field hospital/cemetery.
 
A photo in the info centre of a Canadian field hospital

Lijssenthoek Military Cemetery, Belgium

This cemetery held German headstones as well, much to my surprise.  It seems that during this war, in some parts of the front, wounded German prisoners of war received the same quality of medical care that the Entente soldiers received.  This is a tremendous contrast to later conflicts during which POWs were treated like animals rather than human beings. 

After another cemetery along the former light rail lines, we stopped in Poperinghe (Petit Ypres) to check out the area where the shooting post remains. The shooting post, as you have guessed, is the post to which deserters of the British forces were tied for execution by firing squad.  A couple of Canadian soldiers were executed for desertion.  In a cell in Poperinghe, adjacent to the shooting post is a collection of a number of holding cells, their walls made of blocks of chalk.  On one of those walls, one of the soon to be executed Canadian soldiers carved a facsimile of his hat badge. 

The Canadian hat badge carved into the wall 

The shooting post
Needless to say, this space was not a pleasant one in which to hang out for any length of time so I made note of the place, took photos of the carving in the wall, and made my quick exit.  Between the cramped cell, the limited light, and the ooze of terror, shame, and injustice seeping from the place, I really could not be in the space for long.  My skin was crawling from all that I have just described.  I was happy to leave that space and head over to the café for a coffee with “the boys.”












After Poperinghe, we moved on to another fairly large cemetery: Reninghelst New Military Cemetery.  I enjoyed this cemetery for its diversity.  Here there were a number of different nationalities which I had not seen represented previously in other cemeteries.  An example of this is the representation of members of the Chinese Labour Corps who worked on the major projects of the war such as the building of rail lines, communication trenches, services, sapping (tunneling), and all other manner of labour required to keep the war machine moving. 


A Good Reputation Endures Forever is inscribed on many of these headstones, along with the name of the individuals in Chinese characters.

In addition to the Chinese headstones, I also found a number of South African headstones with the information and personal inscriptions written in Afrikaans, illustrating the policy of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission (CWGC) that the culture and language of the individuals serving in the war would be preserved and honoured on their headstones – an interesting policy from a country that was hell-bent on homogenizing the planet through imperialism…but I digress.

In 100% contrast to Poperinghe and the shooting post, Norm took us to La Plus Douve Farm Cemetery, one of the most beautiful cemeteries I had visited during the entire trip – easily in my top three.  This tranquil cemetery is part of a working dairy farm, nearly smack in the middle of the farm, actually.  To the right of the cemetery is a shell crater which over time has become a beautiful pond complete with bulrushes and water lilies.  The farmer has built a wharf and decking at the edge of the “pond” allowing sunbathers to bask in the sun near the water on days like the day we were there.  One hundred year old oak and maple trees surround the cemetery, shading the roses and lavender blooming beside the headstones. 
La Plus Douve Cemetery
A weeping willow tree grows in the far right corner of the cemetery (when the pond is on your right), an extraordinary place to sit, prop up against its trunk, and read for a while.  One could very easily forget that this place was a cemetery – it felt more like a park or a private garden…hushed with love and peace.  There was absolutely no anguish here.  This would be a place where the souls would swim and fish and dream in the willow shade for eternity…completely in peace.  All one could do in the presence of all this was just to sigh.  Really.  Just to sigh.

The last couple of stops I want to mention were, to no one’s surprise, in contrast to the  La Plus Douve Cemetery.  Voormezeele Enclosure is the final resting place for a number of soldiers Norm affectionately referred to as “Agar’s boys.”  Agar Adamson was a key figure to many of the “lads” from some of the Ontario divisions.  He was an older man when the war started and quickly became a father figure for many of the young men in his command.  In the Voormezeele Enclosure, at least four of Agar’s officers and some of his soldiers are buried.  Agar kept a detailed journal and wrote to his wife daily, sometimes more than once per day.  Through his journal and his letters, his days in the Great War can be vividly recalled. 

The dates on the headstones of Lt. Donald Ewan Cameron, Lt. F. D. Farquhar D.S.O (Distinguished Service Order), Lt. H.C. Buller D.S.O, and  H. G. Bellinger coordinate with many of Agar’s letters and his description to his wife of the loss of these men. He was heartbroken by the losses.  His letters and biography have been lovingly reprinted by Norm Christie and can be purchased through his web site CEF Books.  Look ‘em up.  The letters are beautifully written and give a high ranking officer’s view of the war – from a commander who, contrary to the stereotype of the Great War, cared a great deal for his “boys.”  Agar was a gentleman when being a gentleman was a way of life.  Check him out.  You will not be disappointed.

The Voormezeele Enclosure also gave me an example of someone who had died under an assumed name but whose name was found out after his death and engraved on his headstone.  Norm had told us about these stones but, until now, I had not found one.  This stone was particularly interesting because not only did this young man enlist under an assumed name, he also enlisted as a completely different religion. 

Joseph Page enlisted in the 18th battalion of the Canadian Expeditionary Forces (CEF) and died in Flanders on April 10, 1916. 
When Norm did his research into this young man, he discovered that Joseph identified himself as a Christian on his enlistment papers.  Joseph many have served as Joseph Page, Christian but, back home, Joseph was Joseph Rousinhtol whose family was of Jewish faith.  All of this was discovered when the family returned the paperwork after Joseph’s death.  So, Joseph is buried under a Star of David rather than a Latin Cross. 

The Served As inscriptions made me imagine an entire, complex back story for this soldier – one where he was afraid to “out” himself as Jewish for fear of…discrimination?...harassment?...isolation?  All are very possible from what I have read about the lives of Jewish soldiers in the British forces – most notably the poet Isaac Rosenberg, who was brutally treated by other soldiers in his corps. 

Brutal.  Fear enough to denounce your faith - the faith of your ancestors.  In death, at least, his ancestors found him.

After a few more stops, our day was winding down.  We stopped so Scott could grab some pics of a monument to some of the fliers of the war.  At this particular stop, Norm explained the march to Kitchener’s Wood which took place late one night in April 1915.  We looked across a potato field to a copse of trees in the distance – Kitchener’s Wood today.  I tried to capture it in a photograph…to little success.

Beside where we parked was a large dairy farm, the farm owned by the family whose potato field leads to Kitchener’s Wood.  Norm has a friendly relationship with this farmer from days when he filmed For King and Empire in this field and encouraged us to wander over to the farm and see if there were any shells in his driveway.  Sure enough.  Just inside of the drive way was a pile of shells and hand grenades ploughed up from his field probably when he planted his potato crop. 
 
The shells from the potato field
Again, in keeping with the day’s leit motif of incongruity, this moment was difficult to process:  these instruments of death found during a process designed to produce life.  A “harvest of iron,” as Scott wrote about it later on the picture of the shells I posted on line.  It really is hard to believe that a century later these shells are still being brought to the surface – many of them still “live” – as if no time has passed.  They are oxidized and often mud encrusted but are still deadly.  Crazy!

We meandered our way back to Ypres, past a farmer’s field with four cement bunkers still as intact as they were a century ago; horses and cattle grazing around them…just a meaningless piece of their environment…a bizzaro world of green grass, summer sunshine, and scars of a one hundred year old war.  Just didn’t seem to match up in my head.

Later that night, as I re-packed my suitcase, I thought about that field, the shells, and the farms and thought about how amazing this place was:  this beautiful country with its rich fertile fields appearing for all the world like an Eden but, for those who know the history of the places, carrying, deep in its soil, the soul wrenching anguish of loss, destruction, and barrenness.

I was happy that we still had a few more hours to spend, the next day, in this land of contrast.  I wanted a little more before heading home.  I wasn’t quite done yet.





Monday, 31 August 2015

The Bearable Lightness of Being: July 22 from August 31

I have been home for over a month and have not really finished the commentary on my trip.  I did not mean for that to happen – it just sort of did.  I also needed a little time and distance to really process the trip, how it affected me at the time, and how, with hindsight, I have been changed by the whole experience.  So let me catch you up on the last part of the trip and I will also share with you a couple of my experiences that I didn’t have a chance to share with you while they happened.

My last entry was on the 22nd of July when I shared my breakthrough around the difference between feeling the grief of those sacred places and stealing the grief – making the experience about me and not the dead.  Not cool and not healthy.  I also shared what I had learned about the lessons the cemeteries teach and how not all of those cemeteries are soaked in sadness; how some of them are peaceful and really lovely.  

The 22nd was a very busy day.  We had, as usual, a jam-packed day of cemetery visits but on this day, there were a series of experiences which brought me to those moments of clarity.

I actually started the day really early so I could get into Ypres (not the modern spelling but I just can’t use Iepres) and take pics of the city without all of the other tourists milling around. 


St. Mathew's Cathedral, Ypres
The Ypres cloth hall
The Menin Gate road


The morning was beautiful and, as you can see, I got some really wonderful images.

What I see now, from this distance, is that the day was all about the massive scale of loss in this part of the Western Front during those four years of destruction.  The columns and columns of names on the Menin Gate made an impression on me the day before when we did our town tour with Norm but I didn’t really have the time to soak it all in.  


That morning when I was alone with those names, the weight of it really hit me.  It really felt like the names went on forever – the Canadian names – from a country that really did not have much of a population to begin with yet. 

 

Name after name after name.  They flowed over me – a surge of lives, of longing, of loss.  At the time, I did not realise that this was the theme of that day.  So many lives.  So much loss.  And just under the surface, I now see, was this ache:  all of those names represented men whose bodies were never found.  The only way we know, their people know, they were there is from the letters carved in this marble on these slabs.

[I know my tenses get all funky but I find myself going back to the moment and experiencing it in a “present tense” kinda feel.  Please exercise patience with my “tense jumping.”  Thank you.]

I really felt the weight of the emptiness.  Perhaps that was the beginning of the lesson I wrote about that night after returning to my room:  the duty to put stories to those letters in the marble so the lives of those missing men rematerialize – flesh out the holograph of who they were.  Make them real again and, in so doing, give them all chances at immortality…not for any great heroic propagandistic bullshit (as I learned since from Louis Barthas, barrel maker, in the memoir Poilus, many of those “common soldiers” were there because they had no choice – no heroism for them…just muddy, bloody death)…but because they had no other choice but to die when told to do so.  To me that is a pretty good reason to have someone, 100 years on, give your death some meaning somehow; to give the life meaning, too.

And this was just the first half-hour of that day, in a day filled with moments just like that one.

When I got to the top of the stairs (the Menin Gate has stairs to the left and right around the centre section) and stepped into the garden, one of my tour buddies was there – Elaine.  She was of a similar mind and, clearly had the same idea to get a moment alone with the names on the gate.  I asked her if she wanted to be alone but she said she had her moment.  We wandered around Ypres together – her following me and I have no sense of direction – eventually ending up back at the hotel for breakfast, albeit a little later than she wanted.  I grabbed some more pics of the buildings of Ypres and got myself psyched for the rest of the day

This day had several stand out moments and seem to have the theme established by my morning at the Gate.  This day we visited:  Langemark Cemetery, St. Julien (The Brooding Soldier Memorial), Canada’s Road, Tyne Cot Cemetery, and a couple of really beautiful cemeteries in the middle of a forest (Woods Cemetery and The Bluff Cemetery).  Of course there were more but these were the moments that really stood out for me, especially Langemark, Tyne Cot, and Woods/The Bluff Cemeteries.

Langemark. 

Anyone who has visited feels a visceral “catch” at the name.  The thick, black basalt crosses imprint on you – that weight of emptiness again…like those names in the marble.  

Langemark Cemetery


All I could think about was Kathe Kollwitz's sculptures The Grieving Parents, and the same ache returned from earlier in the day at the Gate. 

Here, though, unlike the Gate, there was another layer of pain.  Langemark is a German cemetery for recovered bodies and for the missing in the Ypres salient.  The names of their dead, the dead, young student soldiers who died “...like children…” (in the words of Eric Maria Remarque from All Quiet on the Western Front) are carved in oak in a small room at the front of the cemetery. 

Imagine being an “enemy” buried in the land you and your comrades “lost” to.  Such a heavy burden for a truly proud people.  The complexity of feeling is so palpable there, especially as a German.  My father’s people were Prussian, immigrating to Canada in the 1880s.  My mother’s father was also of German heritage…so much blood of “the Hun” in my viens.  

Some subterranean, subtle shame lingers there – coats the soil with its oily layer, never really dispelled.  Hitler’s visit there during the Third Reich doesn’t really help the situation, either. 

Shame after shame after shame. 

Now that I think about it, I felt that same feeling at Neuville-St. Vaast, and Caix German Cemetery, two other German cemeteries filled with those black iron crosses.  How must it have been for families of those men/boys?  Your sons lie in the fields of those who cursed you and wished all manner of ill will upon you even though your “boys” were only doing the same duty as the others.  How would those souls ever find peace with such anger directed at them?

To add insult to injury, Langemark was being “cleaned up” by moderns.  This made me really angry.  What kind of arrogance to think that we can improve on what was created to show respect to those who rested there immediately after the conflict?  Those basalt crosses were being moved and the other pieces of Art placed there were missing (the Grieving Comrades iron sculpture was missing, for example).  This issue is best left for another post altogether…I have lots of ire for those who think they know better than the originators of these sacred places.

After Langemark we headed over to the Brooding Soldier Monument at St. Julien.  This is a powerful monument but it somehow lacks connection.  Norm explained that the monument site was chosen for maximum visibility, not for historical reasons.  The actual location of the battles for which the monument was built is several miles ahead and over, in the middle of a farmer’s field.  The Canadian government decided to place it on a street corner rather than connect it to the actual location of importance.  Not really that surprising because…government.  The lack of connection I felt now made sense.  Nice sculpture, no soul.  Kinda defeats the purpose.

The Brooding Soldier Monument


Norm took us to the place where the Brooding Soldier should have been:  the location where the Canadians held the bulge/the break in the lines at Passchendaele. 

Passchendaele.  The name, like so many others in this place, is steeped with so much…anguish, pride, I dunno…confusion, betrayal.  This cocktail of emotion reminds me now, in hind-sight, of Beaumont-Hamel:  the charnel house that was one of the Somme Battlefields.  The main difference is that those who lived in the mud of Passchendaele, at least came out “victorious” in more battles than they did on the Somme.  There was, at least a sense of justification in the loss in some ways…that pride I spoke of.  Like at Vimy, the Canadians held on there when no one else could. 

At the end of a street, aptly titled “Canada’s Road,” is a very small park bracketed by houses on the one side and massive corn and wheat fields on the other.  In the center of the park is a stone block to mark the place the Canadians held.  As a monument it totally lacks any imagination and heart (another topic for another time).  The Brooding Soldier would have been a perfect marker for this spot.  Standing “…on guard…” for those enriching the fields all around that site. 

Canada's Road
The Passchendaele monument

The fields surrounding the park in Passchendaele


Like Beaumont-Hamel, this little park at the end of Canada’s Road, made me uneasy.  Like there was unfinished business there, somehow…a frenetic energy waiting for release.  Maybe that’s what was so unsettling about those sites: not the grief but the longing, the waiting, the wish to be free from the burden of that soil, that sarcophagus of mud.












Tyne Cot Cemetery


Tyne Cot Cemetery was the next stop; another note in the theme begun in the early morning in Ypres at the Menin Gate. 

Tyne Cot is massive.  Easily the largest cemetery we visited on this trip.  Facts:  it is the largest Commonwealth Cemetery in the world, holding 11, 871 Commonwealth graves – 966 Canadians (554 are unidentified).  In addition to the graves, there are names of an additional 34,000 British, 1179 New Zealanders, and 1 Newfoundlander with no known graves carved into the marble slabs at the back of the cemetery…nearly 50,000 souls memorialised here.  There are so many burials that the Cross of Sacrifice sits atop ten layers of marble slabs (the height and size of the CoS indicates the number of dead found in the cemetery).  To give you an idea of the impact of this in relation to other sites:  the Cross of Sacrifice of smaller cemeteries sits atop one or two marble slabs, depending upon the number of dead in the cemetery.

This place gave me one of my three “break down” moments of the trip.  The “break down” I wanted could not take place and needed to be much more subtle because the cemetery was very busy.  I perched myself atop the marble slabs, under the Cross of Sacrifice, and tried to capture the size of the cemetery with its nearly literal sea of headstones.  I couldn’t.  There were too many to fit into one panorama shot (in my camera, as I am sure in others, a panorama shot is made from three regular sized pictures).  I needed nearly three.

The ocean of headstones at Tyne Cot Cemetery
Sitting up there it hit me, just as hard as it did earlier that morning, all of those stones were people – someone’s son, father, brother, husband, fiancée, boyfriend, student, friend…someone’s beloved.  And they died far, far away from home. 

The volume, the sheer numbers can numb you when you read them but when you sit among “…the millions of mouthless dead…” as Charles Sorley called them, you feel it…the weight of emptiness, as I called it earlier…a white noise of feelings, voices, souls. 

Every current of energy there that day was reaching out: the longing to connect; the desire to remember and be remembered; the desperation to fill the void of time and death, to touch the dead, to heal the living now and then. 

It was both fascinating and exhausting to be there.  So much going on.

After a few more stops, our official day was over and Norm drove back to the hotel to give people the option to go see more of Ypres and have the opportunity to get supper before the nightly Last Post ceremony at the Menin Gate.  Anyone else who wanted to see some more cemeteries could stay in the van and head out with Norm and Scott.  I came on this trip to see cemeteries, not shop, so I stayed behind with Norm and Scott and one other tour member and off we went.

On this impromptu trip is where I got my best education.  We visited several hidden gems: Woods Cemetery, The Bluff, and Hedgerow Cemeteries – several of the most peaceful cemeteries I had visited since Bedford House Cemetery on our first day in Belgium.  The last two were hidden in a forest off of a side road off of a side road.  To reach The Bluff and Hedgerow, you had to walk through a field into a forest and follow a labyrinth of dirt foot paths.  The cemeteries appeared out of the middle of the forest like fairy rings:  green, lush, and surrounded by the beautiful flowers: blue hydrangeas, lavender, corn flowers. 

Hedgerow Cemetery


One of the packs at Hedgerow Cemetery
Contents of one of the packs at Hedgerow Cemetery

Hedgerow even had three or four kit packs on marble slabs outside of the cemetery.  The packs had been preserved in a resin of some kind and the contents of the kits had been preserved in a block of yellowing epoxy - the DNA in the amber holding the secrets of yesterday.  The packs gave the cemetery weight, a presence, making the place personal – those straps touched someone who maybe rests here.  Seeing it now, I feel like those packs comforted me somehow…the weight was no longer empty…there was body there – the fleshed out hologram.

I think, too, that the feeling of substance I experienced at Hedgerow came out of the lesson I learned from Norm at Woods Cemetery.  My post on the 22nd was dominated by that lesson: the “you can’t go there” lesson.  The lesson of not making the sadness about me.  The lesson of not putting myself in a place of grief that I could not possibly understand.  The lesson of not borrowing the sorrow of others.  It was almost like Norm helped me find my place in this whole process – the process of processing the history of this place…an appropriate connection to the emotions of the history without making it about me.  I’ve already written about this so I won’t go into it any further than that. 

I will, however say that it was a perfect way to end that day.  Everything seemed to come full circle:  from the heaviness of emptiness and separation to the healing power of connection; finding a way to honour those names, whether carved in marble or oak, with peace rather than sorrow; and from the white noise of the restless dead to the places where they have found peace. 

The day was complete.  Perfect.  The best way to prepare for those final days in this epicentre of sacred places.






Wednesday, 22 July 2015

A New Lens

I know I said I was going to write about the screaming trench at Beaumont-Hamel but I have decided to move that to another day.

I want to share some of my “ah ha” moments which most likely will be “no brainers” to military historical buffs but for me have become moments of clarity which have shifted my whole perspective on all of my WWI interest. 

My passion for the conflict and the Canadian involvement in this has been focused on something beyond the loss and the grief and the pain and I have Norm Christie and Scott D. to thank for that.  Their perspectives and searches for the names of the missing and nameless soldiers have re-framed my experience of this time period and those who lost their lives in the horrific conflicts..

Let me explain:  Norm has made a career about increasing the visibility of the sacred places, not only here in France and Belgium, but around the world for the major 20th century conflicts in which Canadians have found themselves.  He has made it his mission to put a name on every nameless grave marker, a face to the name, and a soul to the stone.  He works tirelessly to make sure the world understands the details of the battles, yes, but more importantly, he impresses upon us that we must find and tell the stories of the men behind the markers.  We must tell their stories over and over and over to give them the immortality they deserve.

We must be servants to life not messengers of death.

Scott, a fellow traveler who had done this same tour six times, has learned well from Norm and also collects metals, postcards, letters, and pictures and also searches for the men behind the effects.  He has even placed a name to an unidentified airman (to name just one) of the Great War.  Now this once anonymous man has his name back and will not be forgotten.

That is really what all of this is about for Norm and others, like Scott, who have learned well from Norm:  tell their stories AND HAVE CLARITY OF PURPOSE FOR DOING SO!  Just collecting metals and such to have or viewing the memorials to go there is not enough to free the lost from their purgatory of anonymity. 

Every time I thought about doing a tour to these sacred places, I really believed I would be crippled with grief and weighed down the whole time by the pain and anguish of the place.  I believed that the ghosts would constantly scream, and I would have little or no way of drowning them out in my head.  I honestly thought I would be depressed for the entire trip.

Thanks to a few incremental, but profoundly important little “light bulb” moments, despair changed to hope.  Not only that, the story of the battles has come to life because Norm taught me how to listen to the stories as told by the cemeteries.  The gravestones tell us who was there, when the devastation took place, and which groups worked with (or against) each other.  Through the examination of the grave stones, you can tell if tanks were there, airplanes, infantry, cavalry, and so on.  


For me, the most freeing lesson has been two fold: 














       1)    Contrary to my assumption, not all memorial sites are stained with grief.  Some sites are still grief-filled for sure but some are horrified, angry, and even resigned.  Some sites are peaceful and free.  I would never have anticipated this, but some sites have released its sadness and have moved on to peace and maybe even pride.
I have visited some exquisitely beautiful cemeteries (out in the middle of nowhere) which are utterly peaceful.  Those souls are perfectly ok with where they are.
Hedge Row Cemetery





(2)     After a very philosophical discussion with Scott – after a lesson-filled day with Norm – I realise that should I choose to locate the names and information of the people whose post cards and pictures I have, they will not be nameless either.  When one hunts down the names of the men who earned the medals, or when one discovers the name of the “Soldier of the Great War,” life is breathed back into them.  As I have said before, the process becomes more about remembrance and honouring the dead and less about mourning them.


(3)     I was helping Norm locate a couple of stones and, while he was off photographing the one stone, I located the other.  The inscription on the stone, as placed there by the family was as follows:  A. A. Briggs  2nd BN. Canadian Inf.  26th April 1916, Age 23
                                                            All we had.
                                                            Loved and Deeply Missed
                                                
                                                             By Father and Mother
            

              Both the inscription and the age of the soldier when he died hit me hard.  My oldest son, Dylan is 23 years old.  And “All we had,” is eviscerating.  How many mothers and fathers lost all they had?

When Norm came over to take the picture and read the inscription, he also commented on how moving it was and shared the inscription which always moves him:  O for the touch of the vanished hand or the sound of the voice that is still,  as found on F.J Jones’s grave.  I agreed with him that this inscription is moving and added that what got me was that Briggs was the same age as my oldest son.
  
Norm’s reply:  “Oh…you can’t go there.”

He eloquently described how this whole process of naming the unknown soldiers and looking around the cemeteries would be unhealthy if a person “went there.” 

I have since also come to the conclusion that if I “go there,” I am just piggy-backing my own grief/pain issues on to them…and that is blatantly disrespectful.  I need to keep my shit straight.  To be moved by the beauty of the words is one thing, to borrow sorrow because I need an excuse to feel sad is another.

The dead who feed this land deserve better than to have someone steal their spotlight.


I am leaving here soon and when I go, I will leave with a focus on life and leave death to the dead.

Tuesday, 21 July 2015

Finally. Again.

I have written a couple of times about my connection to the novel All Quiet on the Western Front, but what I have never written about is how I continued from AQWF and tried to learn as much as I could about the Great War…which led me to Pierre Burton’s Vimy. 

Vimy brought the battles for Vimy Ridge in April of 1917 to life.  The stories of the men involved were vivid and riveting.  The overlapping story structure allowed me to get into and stay in the action with the men.  I learned so many more stories; learned about their lives and their deaths.  The more I read, the more I reacted strongly to the stories of valour, horror, and grief.  I learned, quickly to love the men on the Ridge and to feel a profound sense of pride in their ability to take the Ridge in a little over 8 hours when no one else could in 3 years. 

The soil of the Ridge had been fed with French blood since early days in the war during the fall of 1914 and into 1915.  The Germans had this territory and they were not about to give it up. 

The view from the Ridge is for tens of kilometers in all directions.  It is a plum military position.


After reading of the new tactics created by Canadians, executed by Canadians, and mastered by Canadians, I felt a sense of pride I had not really experienced in that way before. In addition, I had become very curious about military tactics and wanted to learn more.  Of course, the thing about the Great War, once you slip down the “rabbit-hole” that is the Great War, you find out very quickly that this war is all about catastrophic loss of life.  

A solder at the time went so far as to describe the feeling of the age, especially on the front and in the military culture, that life was cheap…humans were completely expendable. The job of the army was to win at all cost and the job of the soldier was to die for that victory – to pay that cost.

Hundreds of thousands of lives have been spent for small parcels of land. 

Seeing it 100 years later, in the form of graveyards, is life altering.  There are millions of grave stones and every stone symbolises a life lost.  Every stone has a story – compelling, intriguing, and very often heart wrenching. And thanks to Norm Christie, our tour meister and Canadian Great War guru, those stories have come to life in the cemeteries.

The monuments and the cemeteries are necessary to compel us to remember those stories; those men whose lives were treated so cheaply.  In these monuments we see the perfect marriage of the power of Art, symbol, and ritual to salve a grieving heart.

For me, no monument has had a more impactful presence than The Spirit of Canada Grieving for Her Lost Sons which is the statue on the front of the Vimy Memorial, looking out onto the Douai plane.  She is the quintessence of maternal grief.

I would stare at her for seconds into minutes into hours.  She was my focus for getting to this place of mud and blood.  I would focus on the iconic image of her looking over the Ridge and force myself into the picture.

On Sunday night I was in the picture, gazing at her over the Douai Plane during the purple Magic time of twilight and had one of the most profound religious experiences I have had in nearly twenty years.

We were supposed to be going to Vimy yesterday but one of my tour mates decided she wanted to see Vimy at night – it could be done…it is lit.  She wanted to experience this.  At first I was cursing her keenness because I was so tired from travelling for days.  In the end I relented, she won us all over, and I am so glad she did.

We stopped at a crater cemetery prior to our stop at Vimy so that by the time we arrived, the sun was perfect. 

I immediately felt in awe of the fact that I was there at all.  This was a life long dream and I was walking in the purple magic of it. 

Each step brought me closer to her.  Closer to that iconic image/location. 
















I stopped to capture the grieving mother and father in pictures and I climbed the stairs to the front of the monument.


When my feet hit the top platform, time slowed to near stillness.  I rounded the top of the platform and saw her.  I was actually in the place I had wished myself to be for 22 years and the whole realization completely overwhelmed me.

There she was.  My muse.

I walked up to her and reached out to touch the hem of her tunic as though I could grab a handful of fabric out of the marble.  My fingers slid over the ripples and I realised I had been sobbing since I reached the top of the platform.

I don’t remember much about being up there with her except I kept whispering: “I can’t believe I am finally here.”  I believed in everything in that moment.  All miracles were possible always.

Upon review of the pictures, I found that I had not only captured her image, but my love for her was also what was being captured.

Here she is.
 
And here is the poem I wrote last year.  I think I need to change the title from August 2015  to July 2015.
August, 2015

I will sit at the feet of the marble mother, 
Frozen with grief,
And I will weep
And grieve so deeply as to crack her marble heart.

I will stand among the Kinderkorp ,
In the cemeteries of the "children corps,"
And see the faces of the boys I would have sent away -
Inspiring and shaming into action
A generation of  youth
And beauty
And truth;
Sacrificed to the dogs of war - 
Grizzle for them to gnaw
And bones with which to pick their teeth.


I will lie on their graves - 
The mother on train,
Staring into space,
Counting on her fingers:
1
2
3
4
5  

Silence

1
2
3
4
5

Counting the sons I've lost
Counting in the train on the way 
To the asylum.
My husband takes me there.

I will dream I am dead
A muddy, 
Bloody boy of 21.

Marching on the Marne,
Ypres,
Verdun,
The Somme,
Vimy,
Passchendaele,
Drowning in fatigue.
Too cold to be hungry.
Too hungry to be afraid.

Finally out of the greasy,
Foetid 
Crater water
Dry enough to smoke
                               -but only in a place hidden from snipers' eyes.

I will dream I am dry
And home
And loved
Forever.

Be ready for me ghosts!
When I come to you,
I will weep
And grieve so deeply,
That my gratitude
Will wake you from the dead.

-R. Elke
August 23/14




Keep in mind that this happened on the eve of the day I found Arthur’s grave. 
Yeah.  Crazy.

And, I have to tell ya, this isn’t even all that happened that day.  The next post will be about the screaming trenches at Beaumont-Hamel.  That will finally take me out of the first day.

God, how am I surviving this?

…and today was the Menin Gate…

Fuck.




Monday, 20 July 2015

Finally...

It is 1am in Arras. 

I need to be up at 6 am but I have to write this out.  I have been holding this for 45 years.  Looking for 45 years.

When I was very, very young (2 or 3), before my sister was born and made him disappear, I had a friend (what we used to call an “invisible friend” back in the day) named Arthur.  Arthur went with me everywhere.  Arthur walked with me, played toys with me, and ate at the table with us.  If you ask my mother today, she would tell you that I would vehemently insist that Arthur have a place set because he needed to eat.  Every meal a complete place had to be set for him by my mother.  At first she was annoyed but after a while, Arthur became a regular part of our dinner routine.

I remember talking to him for hours on my toy phone.  He would tell me stories about his travels.  From time to time he would go away and have adventures and then he would come back or call me and tell me all about them. 

He was my best friend.  I loved him very much.

Then one day my mother brought home a squalling bundle from the “hospital,” where-the-fuck-ever that was, and Arthur went on an adventure and never returned.

I searched for him for days. 

The receiver on my toy phone was dead.

Silent.

Even now as I write this, 45 or so years later, I feel the pain of loss – my heart was broken.  Where was Arthur?  Where could he have gone?

Why didn’t he say goodbye?

The receiver stayed silent until my first day in Arras, when I was in the threshold between asleep and awake, and the young man stood beside my bed asking me to find him.

I should have known, when I looked in my father-in-law’s war graves book, and found an Arthur Rutherford in it.  Rutherford is my Granny’s maiden name and it was at my Granny’s where I would have the best talks with Arthur.  I think it was at Granny’s that he spoke to me for the first time.

When I found an Arthur George Rutherford in my father-in-law's book, I had a feeling it could be him.

Yesterday, as we approached the Sunken Road Cemetery, I had a feeling it could be him.

When I opened the “cubby” to read his name on the list of the dead, I had a feeling it was probably him.

I stepped into the grave yard and turned to my right to walk over to his grave and the second stone in the grave yard was engraved with the last name Dewar – Dewar is one of my daughter’s middle names.

This meant I was in the right place.

When I stepped in front of his grave stone and read his name.  I felt a sigh of relief ripple through me…

I found him.  

Again.

There is a link death cannot sever
Love and Remembrance live forever.




Saturday, 18 July 2015

Zen and the Art of Touring...in France

Travelling in France, I am learning very quickly, is a game of hurry up and wait.  No one is any huge hurry to complete tasks.  All in good time.  All will be well.

Met up with the rest of the tour peeps today.  Waited for one member to find us because he went to the wrong gate.  CDG is huge and confusing.  No harm done.  Waited for an hour and a half to get the van we needed to make our trip north to Arras.  For the first 45 minutes or more during the wait, the line in which our tour guide waited did not move a bit.   Ok.  Gave me a chance to get to know some of the members of the group.  No harm done.  Breathe.  All will be well in it's own time.

The drive up was beautiful.  It was a lovely day - sunny and much cooler than it was yesterday.  The van had A/C, too, which helped a lot.

Mile after mile of wheat fields spread out across the undulating landscape, reminding me of Alberta and some parts of Saskatchewan.  The golden blanket immediately reminded me of being a small child in Saskatchewan, driving in the farm truck with my grandfather – and sometimes the giant grain truck – to take the wheat to the elevator.  There is really something breath taking about those fields.

One one thousand-
Two one thousand-

…holy shit!  These fields are full of century old war dead.  Their blood has, literally, fertilized this soil.  Their bones feed the corn and the wheat and those who consume the bread from those grains.  Those bodies nourish us – literally.  The nourishment of the sacrifice…no wonder so many poets, painters, and writers used Christ as a symbol for the Great War Soldier.  It makes so much more sense now.

We checked into our hotel and rested. 



While I napped, I had an interesting experience:  First of all, God help me, I am starting to dream in French.  That could be a good thing if I get separated from the group and need to forage on my own.  Secondly, during my nap I dreamed that someone was calling me, faintly, from far away.  As the voice got closer I noticed it was a young man.  He told me he needed me to find him.  He stood beside my bed in my dream for a few seconds.  He faded as I awoke.  All I was left with was this voice, softly pleading:  “find me.  Find me.  Find me”  Hamlet’s father’s ghost begging Hamlet to swear to avenge his death:  Swear…Swear…Swear.   The sacred three.

Problem:  I don’t know who this lad is.  I don’t know how to find someone who is nameless in a land filled with nameless someones.  Someone’s father, son, brother…  I did bring a list of names with me and I dreamed about someone named Nick Parsons before I left Mission.  I just didn’t look up Nick’s resting place. *sigh*  I guess I’ll have to just look.

Arras is a beautiful town.  The architecture screams Flemmish influence, as created by the one of the many original people to settle the area.  The facades crumble on some buildings but have been maintained very well on others. 

Cobblestone streets and squares are everywhere.  There is so much to take in.  I am glad we are here for three days.  I need some time to wander and take more pics.


The Grand Place



















 Tomorrow is a tour around to some of the grave yards and memorial sites.  I guess it’s time to find the lad from my dream.




Friday, 17 July 2015

The Roller Coaster Ride That is not Paris Disney

My first day was really an emotional roller coaster.  I guess you could say it was my first day on the ride.

I should share that really, I am not under any circumstances a fan of roller coasters…like at all…so this whole business has been jarring for a non-roller coaster person. 

The first step into the “roller coaster car” (if we’re going to keep going with that analogy) was the whole anxiety thing I have about getting through security with ease.  Domestic travel for me is always about who is going to like my tattoos at security and who feels that I need to be a “randomly selected” individual for extra screening.  I was very anxious that this would be the case for international travel.  And that my liquids were not small enough. Or that the plastic bag was too full. Or that my electronics would take too long to turn on. Or…..

Security was a breeze.  My tattoos did not phase anyone (they were busy trialling a new scanner that moves the plastic bins without the helping hands of the screeners…and it was not cooperating), my liquids were fine (phew! I got to keep my hairspray), and I was super early with enough time to peruse the duty free stuff, eat, and wait for the plane.

Learned that leg room is more important than cramming a bag full of shit I didn’t even look at on the flight (note to self…on the way home check the suit case and put computer bag in overhead bin…have little bag for books and snacks for under seat ahead).  Oh, even more importantly:  AISLE SEAT FOR A 9 HOUR FLIGHT!!!!!  Waiting 5 hours to pee because the dude on the aisle was asleep for 3 hours is not a great way to avoid kidney stones.  However, I did learn how to live on the minimum number of sips of liquid so as not to overwhelm my bladder. I feel so much wiser already.

I tried to sleep on the plane but my body is still set on BC time so it was only 11pmish when we landed at CDG airport.  I was pretty tired, though…sort of stumbled out of the plane with the rest of the weary travellers (almost literally – my ankle almost gave out on steel step three of the airplane steps – that woulda been cool….my hands full of suit case and computer bag).  Customs was a breeze and off I went to find my hotel…finally.

Got to my room and felt super overwhelmed.  The whole process of coming to the terminal where customs is was different – you have to take a bus shuttle from the plane to the terminal because at the economy flight terminal there is no disembarking connector to a building.  Ok.  Did that.  Didn’t know what to expect at customs (they just stamped my passport) and was anxious about having to speak French (it’s rusty…to say the least).  And when I paid for my room, it was a little more than I expected, even with the extra charge for early check in. 

Also, I’m travelling alone – kinda overwhelming when there is no one to bounce ideas off of.  Heightens my discomfort level so much and I have lived so much of my adult life trying to avoid discomfort – or creating it on my own terms…

By the time I plunked my bags down in my room, I was seriously ready to shut the blinds, have a shower and sleep all day…to avoid going into Paris alone and having to – gasp – muddle through speaking my shitty French. 

My anxiety nearly paralysed me.  I felt so overwhelmed with all of the stuff I had to do to go to museums, get a ticket for the train.  (Train?!  Fuck! What train do I take?)  I really couldn’t bare it.

Thank Goddess for computers.  I sat and looked up the shit I needed to know and just got the fuck on with it.

I am so glad I did because I would have not had the first of the “one of the most amazing moments of my life” I am sure this trip is going to offer me:

                I just grabbed a train ticket and a museum pass and trained down town Paris (same as skytraining/West Coast expressing…ok…cool – anxiety starting to lower).  I had followed the directions I researched and learned that my connecting train was out of order because of upgrades.  I had to walk from Notre Dame.  I had no map, no list of what building/place was what.  I just took my knowledge of Paris landmarks I learned from Assassin’s Creed Unity (who said video games were no good…)  and my art history classes and started walking.  My destination:  the Musee d’Orsay.  I decided early to avoid the Louver – too many people – and I had been to great antiquities museums in Berlin so...  Also, fin de cycle type art is more my thing – y’know impressionists, expressionists – that sort of thing. 

There is so much history here - and I forgot that feeling from when I was in Germany 30 (ahem) years ago – that I felt like my head was going to explode.  I kept walking.  I passed a statue I recognized (sorry – not great with statues…paintings are my thing…and found myself on the Pont Neuf – the place where people put locks on the bridge.  I must confess I don’t know why – I think it is a superstitious thing about locking the love you have for your lover forever.  I had no lock and my lover is at home so I kept walking.



Walked up the Siene and just kept snapping pics and … holy shit  … off in the distance is the Eiffel Tower!  My camera did nothing but make it look like a grey toothpick in the back ground.  I wandered some more and looked across the Siene to see a super impressive looking building (remember I have no map) and think:  “that looks important; guess I should check it out.”  I snap a pic of the façade of the building and walk through the arches into more amazing façade and breath taking statues at the top of the building and…holy shit, it’s the Louvre! 

Snap. Snap. Sn…

I stop dead in my tracks.  It’s the Arc de Triomphe. 
I really did not expect it to be in this place and I just stopped.  My eyes filled with tears.  The sight of the golden chariot driver caught my breath.  I couldn’t move for a few seconds…this thing is ROMAN…ancient fucking Roman!!!!!!

We poor Canadians, with our baby country, have little or no sense of history – grand ancient history – because we are only a little under 200 years old.  When you are in a place with thousands of years of history it is really a powerful experience.

Needless to say, I snapped a bunch of photos and kept walking on through the gardens and back to the Seine.  And found the Musee d’Orsay! 

There really is something spiritual about coming face-to-face with an art work that you have admired in your head for a long time.  Standing before works of art created by artists you have loved for a long time is intoxicating.  A friend of mine posted a special word for that feeling/experience and it was that word that I kept thinking about as I wandered the Musee d’Orsay.  Monet, Cezanne, Pissaro, Toulouse Lautrec, Gauguin, right before you. 

The most beautiful moment, though was walking into a side gallery and gazing upon a Bourgereau piece.  I have a poster of his Abduction of Psyche hanging in my house.  I love his work so much!  And here was this canvas before me…his brush touched this work!  I was enraptured! 
And in this state I wandered the rest of the museum and across the street to a little military museum. 

I decided it was time to wander back and catch a train to CDG and my hotel.  I wandered passed a boulangerie and decided to get food for my dinner at my room and…y’know…it’s Paris so that’s what you do.  So I sucked up my terror of having to speak French and I ordered a sandwich I knew would survive the 35 degree heat on the trek back to the airport.  Jumped on the train to learn that the terminus was not the airport and nearly had a heart attack…oh, and my phone was dying – of course – so any call to a taxi would be out if this train didn’t hook me up later with a transfer zone.  It did, thank the travel gods.

I found my way back to my hotel room, the dust of the Arc de Triomphe still on my feet and my sandals, exhilarated from my communion with art and history and, after a shower and organizing my stuff, I finally got to enjoy the best fucking sandwich with the best fucking bread I have ever eaten.

I was so happy that I hadn’t let my discomfort with the unknown keep me in my airport hotel room for the day!  I would not have had this amazing experience – and sandwich…seriously…the fucking bread!!!!!!   I would have regretted missing that day for the rest of my life!

Holy fuck!  That was day one!  Today I meet up with my tour group and we go off to Arras.  More amazing shit to come.

One wish from yesterday:  I was more organized.  And I would have liked to have had a drink and the pub/restaurant named for Voltaire on the road named for him.  Would have been cool. 

Next time.